Counsel for a shareholder argued Monday afternoon that Tesla should be required to hand over certain board members’ email threads in their entirety, rather than selectively redacting portions that aren’t obviously more privileged.

During a brief virtual hearing before Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick, Joseph Fonti of Bleichmar Fonti & Auld said Tesla is cherry picking what to redact without proving why it should be redacted, while Cravath, Swaine & Moore’s Vanessa Lavely said the fact the redactions are so granular indicates Tesla has only refused to disclose what’s absolutely necessary.