Book Review: ‘I Am Malala’

·

I am Malala

Last week a Facebook friend posted a quote about procrastination. She said:

The work you do while you procrastinate is probably the work you should be doing for the rest of your life.

This leads me to believe that I should be either an eater of chocolate, a librarian, or a full-time reader of books.

I adore books.

All books.

But I especially love memoirs. I am not a fast reader. I regularly pause to ponder on a scene description, or a line of dialogue, or a character’s actions and intentions.

Although the best authors make fictional characters come to life, in memoir, the main character is a real person. That leads to even more thinking because I wonder where she is today, what she is thinking and doing.

And I like to find the common things that bond us as humans, regardless of our ethnic, language and cultural differences.

I Am Malala: A Review

Last year a writer at Whidbey Island Writers’ Conference who had done the voicing for the audiobook introduced me to I Am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban.

Malala Yousafzai is the 12-year-old Pakistani girl who was shot in the face while riding home from school in October 2012.

She was singled out by the Taliban because she had spoken out for the rights of girls to go to school.

Three teachers and twenty girls were crammed into the white Toyota that hot, sticky afternoon, but the gunman was looking for only one: Malala.

I Am Malala has so many layers. It can be read on many different levels, depending on your gender, age, culture, religious faith (or absence of) and, yes, your political leanings.

It is always a danger applying a Western set of eyes to the story of a young woman from an Eastern culture. But that is precisely when I learn the most: when I drop my pretenses and jump into a story with no preconceptions.

That is a hard thing to do, but I try.

You will, of course, want to read it for yourself, but I’m sharing here just a few excerpts from this gem of a book.

On Malala’s homeland before the Taliban

“WELCOME TO PARADISE, it says on a sign as you enter the valley. We have fields of wildflowers, orchards of delicious fruit, emerald mines and rivers full of trout.

“Islam came to the Swat Valley in the eleventh century, when Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni invaded from Afghanistan and became their ruler. We lived in the shadow of the Hindu Kush mountains. Our house was one story and proper concrete. On the left were steps up to a flat roof big enough to play cricket on. It was our playground. At dusk my father and his friends gathered to sit and drink tea there. Sometimes I sat on the roof too, watching the smoke rise from the cooking fires all around and listening to the nightly racket of the crickets.

A valley full of fruit trees on which grow the sweetest figs and pomegranates and peaches, and in our garden, grapes, guavas and persimmons. There was a plum tree in our front yard which gave the most delicious fruit. It was always a race between us and the birds to get them. The birds loved that tree. Even the woodpeckers.”

Sometimes we can almost forget the horrors and violence she experienced when she describes memories in a young child’s voice.:

“From the rooftop I watched the mountains change with the seasons. In the autumn chill winds would come. In the winter everything was white snow, long icicles hanging from the rook like daggers, which we loved to snap off. We raced around, building snowmen and snow bears and trying to catch snowflakes.”

On her sadness leaving her home in Pakistan

While she is in awe of the first world advancements she sees when she travels to England for life-saving medical treatment, still, she is deeply homesick for her homeland.:

“My country is centuries behind this one. Here there is any convenience you can imagine. Water running from every tap, hot and cold as you wish; lights at the flick of a switch, day and night; no need for oil lamps; ovens to cook on that don’t need anyone to go and fetch gas cylinders from the bazaar. Here everything is so modern one can even find food ready cooked in packets.

Now, every morning, I long to see my old room full of things, my clothes all over the floor, and my school prizes on the shelves. Instead I am in a country which is five hours behind my beloved homeland Pakistan and my home in the Swat Valley. “

On gender roles and patriarchy in Pakistan

She is perceptive enough to know that boys are more valued in her culture than girls are.

“I was a girl in a land where rifles are fired in celebration of a son, while daughters are hidden away behind a curtain, their role in life simply to prepare food and give birth to children. For most Pashtuns, it’s a gloomy day when a daughter is born.”

And yet Malala’s father sensed something different about her, even asking his friends to throw dried fruits, sweets and coins into her cradle, something usually done only for baby boys.

By the age of seven she was at the top of her class in a male-dominated school.

But by the time she was ten, the Taliban had come to the valley and soon after, beauty parlors and CD shops closed, polio vaccines for children were stopped and, finally, girls and women were forbidden from going to school. By 2008, 400 schools had been destroyed by the Taliban.

On ancient culture and centuries-old traditions

“We live by a code called Pashtunwali, which obliges us to give hospitality to all guests and in which the most important value is nang, or honor. The worst thing that can happen to a Pushtun is loss of face. Shame is a very terrible thing for a Pashtun man.”

Another part of the code said that a girl from one tribe can be given to another tribe to resolve a feud.

But Malala wondered, “Why should a girl’s life be ruined to settle a dispute she had nothing to do with?”

On the normalcy of ongoing violence 

We are all familiar with fourth grade math class, but when all you have seen all your life is war and fighting, at the time of the Russian invasion of Afghanistan, children in refugee camp schools worked on problems like this one:

“If out of 10 Russian infidels, 5 are killed by one Muslim, how many infidels are left?”

Gives new meaning to the term “story problem.”

But Malala took conflict in stride. It was the only world she knew. She wrote rather matter-of-factly about gunfire and explosions at schools and suicide bombings. She described how children in her village stopped their games of hide-and-seek and started playing army vs. Taliban.

I have not read many stories of life in a war-torn country told from the perspective of a child. If you like to study religions, cultures and history, and care about the future of the world’s children, I think you will enjoy reading Malala’s inspiring and courageous story, too.

Have you read I Am Malala yet? Did you read another good book this summer? Care to share?

10 responses to “Book Review: ‘I Am Malala’”

  1. Sometimes with some people wisdom comes at an early age – for others it never comes. When she was in the news this girl really caught my attention, and I wondered if she would be attacked or simply disappear.
    Most of us are so attached to our gadgets and baubles and social media we forget how beautiful the world can be. It is easy to see why she would miss her homeland.

    This is a beautiful review. Now I have to go and buy yet another book, both for me and my wife.

    Like

    1. I think you would enjoy this one, Hal. It also gave me a glimpse into a way of life that has been at times hard for me to understand. Their traditions are centuries-old handed down over the generations, so most people (especially kids) don’t even question them. It is just the way things have always been.

      Like

  2. Judy, thanks for such a wonderfully layered post. Our exposure to the middle east is so often limited to the sensational. Loved the beautiful sensory descriptions – and what a great model for memoir. I plan to share your post with my mother – she’s busy writing her memoir as well.

    Like

    1. Latanya,

      Go great to hear from you again! How is that book of yours coming along?

      Reading “I Am Malala,” I was struck by how much I love memoirs with a strong sense of setting couple with a good, interesting plot. There is such a balance to strike and I am sure it isn’t easy. I read as many memoirs as I can these days. And your mother is writing one? That is very cool. 🙂

      Like

      1. Judy – thanks for asking. To quote from The Strife of the Chase – http://bit.ly/1CvkiVd – I persist. :-)….Reading memoir is on my list of genres to explore. I never give myself permission to go ahead and commit, yet I know I’m missing out somehow…

        My mother’s writing about uncovering her roots and an Underground Railroad site in the family. I’m excited for her. Btw, she’s already ordered “I Am Malala” !

        Like

      2. Wow, Latanya, good for your mom. What an interesting story! I am launching my Kickstarter campaign on September 15 to find backers so I can finish this book. Best of luck to your mom!

        Like

  3. Thanks for a great post, Judy! In answer to your question, I have been reading some wonderful books this summer (and now heading into fall). I decided to go back and reread all 5 of Doris Lessing’s “Canopus in Argos” series. I’ve read through “Shikasta” and the magical “Marriages of Zones Three, Four, and Five” (think I’ve read that four times by now), and am currently 3/4 through “The Sirian Experiments.” I am once again stunned by Lessing’s ability to zoom out to a galactic perspective and see our struggling planet’s problems in a context that is way beyond our limitations of space and time and prejudice. Even though these were written in the 70’s, the need for her wisdom regarding the human race is just as strong as it was then. It is interesting to hold Malala’s story in the light of Lessing’s writing!

    Like

    1. Well, the danger of writing a book review post is discovering the existence of more good books. I must check out Lessing’s books. Thanks for the tip and good to see you here, my friend.

      Like

  4. Yes! Good to connect. Re. Lessing’s books, you might find them in a library. I bought hardbacks for very little on ABC books – the trick is finding one seller that has most of them. I did buy a paperback a while back, but it disintegrated as I was reading it! They don’t hold up that well over time.

    Like

    1. Hmm. Wonder if they are available on Kindle. I don’t buy print books anymore. Or maybe they are truly out of print. I will be checking into that.

      Like

Leave a comment

Get updates

From art exploration to the latest archeological findings, all here in our weekly newsletter.

Subscribe