If the risk of hackers meddling with Election results is not enough, here’s another reason voting shouldn’t happen on the Internet: the Ballots can’t be Kept Secret.
That’s according to a new report from Verified Voting Foundation, a group that advocates for transparency and accuracy in Elections.
A cornerstone of democracy, the secret ballot guards against voter coercion. But “because of current technical challenges and the unique challenge of running public elections, it is impossible to maintain the separation of voters’ identities from their votes when Internet voting is used,” concludes the report, which was written in collaboration with the Electronic Privacy Information Center and the Anti-Corruption advocacy group Common Cause.
Thirty-two states and the District of Columbia allow voters to return completed ballots by e-mail, Internet-connected fax machine, or Web portal. In most cases, this option is limited to voters who live overseas or are serving in the military. Utah extends it to voters with disabilities. In Alaska, all voters are free to return their ballots using a Web portal.
When votes are returned via the Internet, it’s technically difficult to separate the voter’s identity from the vote, says Pamela Smith, President of Verified Voting, since the server has to know that identity in order to authenticate the voter and record the vote. In the systems that states are using now, “the authentication typically happens at the same time as the voting process,” she says. That’s problematic. A previous experiment tested giving voters PIN codes, but hackers working with the researchers were able to find those numbers and associate them with voters, says Smith.
Gain the insight you need on privacy at EmTech MIT.
According to the report, issued Thursday, 20 states have laws or regulations requiring that voters who return their ballots via the Internet also waive their right to a secret ballot. In eight states, the Secretary of State or Election Officials require that voters do this even though no laws or regulations require it. Washington, Idaho, North Dakota, and Mississippi don’t warn voters that returning ballots via the Internet also means giving up their secret ballot. Montana requires by law that votes over the Internet be secret, even though that’s not technically feasible.
Smith says the trend toward using the Internet in the voting process could lead to the “Erosion” of the Secret ballot. “Almost every state has a requirement that there should be secrecy of the ballot,” she says. In order to allow Internet voting, they’ve had to “carve out a special space” that is exempt from that requirement.
Alaska goes so far as to inform voters that if they vote via the Internet, they are not only waiving their Right to Secrecy but “assuming the risk that a faulty transmission may occur.” Imagine walking into a polling station and seeing a warning like that, says Smith. “How can you field a voting system like that? That’s not right.
Verified Voting Foundation's Recommendations
Engage your state policymakers in a conversation about the importance of the secret ballot; share this report with them.
Protect your secret ballot by marking and mailing your printed ballot, avoiding using fax, email or an Internet website or ballot marking portal for anything other than requesting, and if desired, receiving the ballot.
If you are a military or overseas civilian voter, your voting process starts earlier than for voters who are not overseas.
- Get your ballot early: Request your absentee ballot today, it will be sent out 45 days prior to Election Day! Contact your local election official back home, FVAP.gov, or your voting assistance officer (VAO) to find out how.
- Get your ballot faster: You have the right to receive your blank ballot electronically if you request it. This will give you more time to get it back safely.
- Mark the printed ballot to safeguard the secrecy of your choices. Don't mark "online."
- Mail the printed ballot back. Even if offered, avoid fax, email or uploading your votes to a website or Internet portal.
- If you are a military voter, you can get express return for your ballot at no cost to you. Use the special 11-DoD label. Your ballot should arrive stateside in less than a week, and you can track its progress all the way back.
If you are a non-military/overseas voter voting absentee, check with your election official about how to vote absentee in your state, and when absentee voting begins. Check early so that you can be ready.
- Safeguard your privacy. Even if offered, avoid the use of an online method for marking and/or transmitting votes. Marking ballots without the use of a connection to the Internet is the best way to keep your vote secret.
- Use an inner privacy envelope when mailing back your ballot, and don't sign the ballot itself! Sign only where instructed.
- Mail your ballot back promptly, or if available in your state, drop it in a secure ballot drop-box or at the elections office. Some states let you track your ballot to be sure it arrives safely; check with your local election official.
CLICK HERE for more information about the report and to download the 145 page (PDF) report.
NYC Wins When Everyone Can Vote! Michael H. Drucker
No comments:
Post a Comment